Nevada has spent decades resisting the federal government’s attempts to turn Yucca Mountain into the nation’s nuclear waste repository. However, in the name of creating more jobs for Nevadans, lawmakers now want to explore what else the mountain could become.
Nevada should not be compelled by the federal government to accept a nuclear waste repository its citizens have not approved, nor should lawmakers assume that an alternative facility deserves public support simply because it might provide employment.
The Jobs, Not Waste Act, reintroduced this year by Democratic Sens. Jacky Rosen and Catherine Cortez Masto, would end Yucca Mountain’s nuclear waste licensing process and require a study of alternative uses, including a data center, a defense command facility and a scientific research center. The legislation is framed around creating jobs and stimulating Nevada’s economy.
Nevada has long been expected to provide space for the nation’s military operations, access to mineral resources, land for energy projects and is now experiencing unprecedented data center growth. About 80% of Nevada’s land is federally managed, the highest percentage of federal land ownership of any U.S. state.
The initial proposed repository in Yucca Mountain was selected through a lack of political leverage from Nevada’s congressional delegation. In 1987, Nevada lacked the institutional influence of legislative heavyweights from Texas and Washington state. The decision left Nevada with the burden of fighting a federal policy that had already been written into law.
Nevada’s own elected officials have repeatedly used the promise of jobs and economic growth to justify policies that give corporations access to public resources.
A data center promises jobs. A defense facility promises jobs. Any massive infrastructure project, technically, promises jobs. But workers should not have to be used as political justification for every project that wants access to Nevada’s land and resources.
One example is the state’s data center tax abatement program. In 2015, then-state Sen. Aaron Ford cosponsored Senate Bill 170 alongside Republican state Sen. Michael Roberson. The legislation authorized partial property and sales-tax abatements for qualifying data centers.
Republican Gov. Joe Lombardo has described data centers as an economic opportunity while supporting requirements related to water, energy and infrastructure.
In September, he signed an executive order establishing additional guardrails for data center development, including a requirement that makes developers pay the Local School Support Tax in full. These requirements may represent a change in emphasis, but they do not erase the larger structure of the incentive program.
Ford, now running for governor, has also shifted his position. In August, he announced that he would pause tax abatements for new data centers if elected. Yet he previously cosponsored the 2015 legislation that created the state’s data center tax abatement framework in the first place.
In 2014, Republican Gov. Brian Sandoval signed a package providing approximately $1.3 billion in tax breaks and subsidies over 20 years for Tesla’s Gigafactory. The agreement was promoted as an opportunity to attract investment, create jobs and diversify the state’s economy.
The company received approval for more than $330 million in additional tax incentives for its expansion in 2023. The proposal remained confidential until shortly before the vote, prompting criticism from lawmakers who argued that the legislature had too little time to examine the effects on housing, schools, public safety and other services. The state was once again asked to prioritize a corporation’s expansion before the public had a meaningful opportunity to examine the deal.
A company may benefit from lower taxes, reduced operating costs and access to public infrastructure. Workers may benefit from employment, but they also need wages that keep pace with housing costs, safe workplaces, collective bargaining rights and a meaningful say in their working conditions.
When politicians promise jobs, the promise is often treated as though it speaks for every worker. But a corporation seeking tax abatements and a worker seeking affordable housing, reliable health care and collective bargaining rights do not necessarily have the same interests.
Once a project is presented as a source of employment, questioning its costs can be framed as opposing the people who need jobs. The debate becomes less about whether a deal serves the public and more about whether anyone is willing to stand in the way of economic growth. Yucca Mountain deserves a different standard.
A worker-centered approach to Yucca Mountain would ask whether the jobs would pay wages sufficient enough to support Nevada’s cost of living and whether employees can organize without retaliation.
Any future proposal for Yucca Mountain should come with enforceable labor protections, transparent financial agreements, environmental safeguards and a meaningful role for the communities affected by the decision.
The guise of job creation should not be the means to our lawmaker’s self-interested ends.

