What having dinner with strangers taught me about connection

I had dinner with strangers to prove that connection is not as difficult as we think it is.

Picture this: a dimly lit Italian restaurant. Six place settings. Six strangers trickle in and make their way to table two, not knowing what or who is waiting for them.

I was the first to arrive. I didn’t exactly know how to explain the reservation to the host, but I guess he saw the look of panic on my face and immediately knew what I was there for. As I fumbled for words, he interrupted and asked, “Time Left?” Relieved, I nodded and followed him to a table in the middle of the restaurant. I ordered a glass of wine. A live singer sang an acoustic Beatles set from somewhere in the other room. I wondered if anyone would actually show up. 

Everyone did.

We met on an app. Of course we did. These days, so many of our connections originate online. We apply for jobs online. We date online. We network online. We document our lives online. Why shouldn’t we make friends online?

But the premise of the app is not to connect online – it’s to create a real, in-person connection and hopefully a friendship. It’s an attempt at authenticity in a society that is used to performing. We are used to carefully curating an online presence; we want to be perfectly perceived.

The app that brought us together is called Time Left. It is advertised as a platform designed to pair people together based on a personality algorithm which considers interests, demographics, temperament and many other factors in order to gauge overall compatibility. 

From there, the app matches you with five compatible mystery people and books a restaurant. It does the hard part for you.

All you have to do is show up.

When I mentioned my mystery plans to a friend and told him about Time Left, he gasped and asked, “Time Left, as in, time left to live?” We all laughed, but of course there was an edge to it.

Almost everyone I told about my plans expressed at least a hint of apprehension around the concept. After all, meeting unknown people at a location that is undisclosed until the morning of the event seems at least a little terrifying. Anything could happen.

But the app takes care to book busy, well-known restaurants and typically includes more than one Time Left table full of strangers. As far as I was concerned, there was nothing to be afraid of.

The first stranger to arrive was right on time — a friendly-looking guy in his early 20’s. He shook my hand, and we launched into small talk. I was relieved when I realized he seemed normal. Soon after, the rest trickled in.

Three women in their early twenties, two UNLV students with opposite majors — Physics and Vocal Performance — and one recent out-of-state grad who returned to Vegas after a semester abroad in Korea. 

Two men in their early twenties — one active military and one recent business grad looking to break away from the monotony of his remote work position. 

Lastly, one older, retired woman, who we later found out had joined the wrong Time Left table, but who we took us 20-something under her wings as one of her own.

The conversation was mechanical at first. One person would pose a question, like, “What do you do for work?” or “What are your hobbies?” and each person would take turns answering. It felt like any awkward first dinner date but with six people instead of two. 

When the food came, we began to settle in more with each other. Instead of the interview-style questions, groups of two or three would break off into separate conversations, sharing funny stories or local activity and dining recommendations. I especially enjoyed speaking to the misplaced retired woman, who was full of stories of her two “scaredy cats” and tumultuous skiing history. 

Everyone was willing to stay for dessert. The ice was officially broken. We reviewed our desserts like food bloggers and continued the disjointed but comfortable conversation. 

It wasn’t particularly deep, and it wasn’t life-changing, but I think that was the point. You aren’t supposed to become best friends within the first two hours of meeting a person; relationships have to build from something. You open up as you go along. In this way, the interaction was almost as authentic as any friendship I’ve made in real life.

Think back to the best first date of your life. I bet it felt like a dream — like you met the perfect person and you could talk to them about anything as if they have known you for your entire life, though you only just met hours before. 

How did that turn out?

Did it last? Was it real? Or did it start off strong and fizzle out shortly after?

The point I’m trying to make is that genuine connections typically burn slowly. It can be unrealistic to expect fireworks in any first-time interaction. The fact that there was clear, constant growth in our comfort levels with each other as time went on is a sign that our relationships progressed naturally. We warmed up slowly, but steadily. That’s real.

In the end, we all exchanged socials and said our goodbyes. Maybe we’ll talk again, or maybe we won’t. Either way, we all got what we were looking for: a genuine, in-person connection.

It turns out that it’s not as hard as it seems. 

Recent Articles

Related Stories

1 COMMENT

  1. We lived in Europe for many years and through this experience being part of a group of unknown people was exciting, allowing us to meet people and share experiences. We moved to Las Vegas recently and hope to find restaurants that support this approach. Hope you can make suggestions.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here