Stop Asking Who Had It Worse

March 13th, 2020. A day earlier, a county mandate cancelled all extracurricular activities for high school students. With one email, it was gone: opening night, the big game, prom, graduation — everything in between, gone.

Students returned that Friday and feigned normalcy. After the final bell, another mandate circulated: spring break would begin early. For two groups of students, it would be their last “normal” day of high school — the class of 2020 and 2021. What followed was continuous discourse over which class had it worse.

First picture the senior class of 2020. Their season is over. No final game. No senior trip. The tux/dress bought for prom never leaves its hanger. Graduation is next to disappear. 

They cannot rally, appeal, resist — every action is “for safety.” Maybe there’s a drive-through ceremony. Yet it’s mostly decorative as their diploma has already been picked up from the front office. 

If they are going to college, it will be on Zoom. If not, the last memory of youth becomes associated with what has been taken away. 

Now picture the junior — the future class of 2021. Their extracurriculars are cancelled too. No final game. No final show. No prom.

But there is hope. “Uncertain times” implies temporary. COVID will end — cinematically — by summer. That’s the belief.

It doesn’t. It worsens. 

When school returns, it is entirely virtual. Some throw unofficial senior sunrises off campus, not allowed to step onto the field. The flicker of hope remains — until the first period begins on Google Meet. Cameras off, the teacher frustrated. Every day will soon become identical. 

Homecoming planned, then cancelled. Prom discussed, then cancelled. Senior trips proposed, then ruled impossible. Repeated blows to what senior year was supposed to be.

There is a graduation, but in cohorts, masked, surrounded by whoever chose your time slot. A rite of passage staged in segments; ceremoniously empty.

If you go to college, it begins hybrid — half masked, half online. If not, the last time youth felt real was two years ago. Senior year was entirely digital.

A TikTok trend has begun circulating around the class of 2020 and their prolonged grievance over not having a graduation. The video follows a pattern: someone approaches a stranger, then either asks a harmless question or a mock threat — and all the person has to say to the situation is:

“Did you know I didn’t have a graduation?”

Noticeably absent from this resurgence of 2020 melancholia is the class of 2021. Even in the comment sections of these viral videos, there are irate 2021 graduates asking to be mentioned, to be parodied, essentially to be remembered. 

The discourse lingers: who had it worse — 2020 or 2021?

Efrain Sanchez, class of 2020 and now majoring in hospitality, was asked whether he felt robbed of any experience because of COVID.

“Everything just came really quickly — it was regular one moment, and then before I knew it I was graduating. Well, not really. We had to pick a time slot to grab our diploma from the front office. They organized a parade thing for us, but it just wasn’t the same. After that it was just over.”

When asked who had it worse, Sanchez did not hesitate.

“I honestly think it was us. 2021 knew what they were getting into. For us, it was there one moment, then over. That does things to you.”

Alexa Medel, class of 2021, was asked her take.

“I was having a good junior year — I was on the track team — and I remember being pulled off the field mid-practice and sent home. I didn’t even go to school that Friday. I regret that. That was the last time it felt normal.

“What we came back to was a screen. It was the longest senior year without feeling like one. My school kept saying events were going to happen, then cancelling them.

“We had a graduation, but it was split into groups. I’m not even sure who I graduated with.”

When asked who had it worst, Medel said:

“At least class of 2020 had most of the senior stuff. I know their graduation was weird, but we didn’t have anything. Everything that happened to them happened to us.”

The class of 2020 has become monolithic — the class of lost youth. Quieter is the class of 2021; the former’s loss was immediate, the latter prolonged. Both permanent. 

Now 22 to 24 years old, the same cohort has been described by The Atlantic as being “in crisis,” among the most depressed demographics. The National Institute of Mental Health corroborates these findings, reporting elevated rates of major depressive episodes among 18-25 year olds; the same cohort that encompasses both classes.

Perhaps the question isn’t which class had it worst, but what sequelae the disruption of COVID left behind, and how long they will last.

Recent Articles

Related Stories

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here