Did Nevada voters reject Question 3 in 2024 because they opposed ranked-choice voting, open primaries or both? The measure offered no way to tell.
Question 3 proposed two significant changes to Nevada’s election system: opening primary elections to voters regardless of party registration and introducing ranked-choice voting in general elections. Both reforms would change how Nevadans participate in elections, but they address different problems.
By combining them into a single constitutional amendment, the proposal forced voters to either accept or reject both reforms at the same time.
Nevada should reconsider open primaries and ranked-choice voting, but each deserves its own question.
Open primaries
Primaries are separate elections within political parties to select candidates for a general election. These elections can determine which candidates voters get to choose from in November elections. In some districts, the primary can be more competitive than the general election.
Currently, Nevada uses closed primaries for major-party candidates seeking certain federal and state offices. Registered Democrats vote in Democratic primaries and registered Republicans vote in Republican primaries.
Voters registered as nonpartisan cannot vote in those party primaries. As of Oct. 1, roughly 40% of Nevada voters are registered as nonpartisan, which means 40% of Nevada voters cannot participate in selecting their options for the general election because they aren’t registered to a party.
Imagine a heavily Democratic district where the nominee is overwhelmingly favored to win the general election. Three Democrats compete in the primary, and the winner advances to the November election. A nonpartisan voter who lives in that district cannot choose which of those three Democratic candidates they would like to advance, even though the winner could end up ultimately representing them in the Nevada Legislature.
That voter can still participate in the general election, but by then the most consequential contest may already be over.
Open primaries would give nonpartisan voters an opportunity to participate in that initial election.
Under Question 3’s proposal, candidates would compete in a single election primary regardless of a party affiliation. All Democrat and Republican candidates would run in a single election. The five candidates receiving the most votes would advance to the general election. While political parties have a legitimate interest in selecting their own nominees, voters have the greater stake in determining who advances to compete for public office.
Ranked-choice voting
Nevada currently uses the plurality system for elections, in which the candidate with the most votes wins — winner-takes-all.
For example, consider an election with three candidates. Candidate A receives 40% of the vote, Candidate B receives 35% and Candidate C receives 25%. Candidate A wins, even though 60% of voters chose someone else.
Under ranked-choice voting, voters rank candidates in order of their preference. If no candidate is the first choice for more than 50% of voters, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated and votes are now redistributed for their next highest choice candidate.
A voter whose first-choice candidate is eliminated could have their vote count towards their second choice, allowing voters more freedom to choose who they truly want to vote for instead of worrying about “wasting” a vote by not voting for a candidate from either party.
Two reforms = two questions
Open primaries expand access to the candidate selection process, and RCV gives voters flexibility in choosing between those candidates. Voters would have more say both about who makes it on the ballot and who wins, but these both address fundamentally different issues.
When reforms are bundled together, it becomes harder to build public support for each one independently. By proposing them as a package deal, Nevada lost the opportunity to expand primary participation or adopt ranked-choice voting even if either reform had broad support separately.
Voters who support one reform but oppose the other have to choose between compromising their preferences for either and rejecting or supporting both. Separating the reforms would have given a fairer chance for each to succeed on its own merits.
Nevadans deserve the opportunity to decide whether they want open primaries, ranked-choice voting, both or neither. Put the reforms on separate questions, make the case for each and let voters judge them independently.
Under Article 19 of the Nevada Constitution, petitions for constitutional amendments can begin circulating as early as “Sept. 1 of the year before … the election is to be held.” Efforts for the 2028 election can begin next September. Each would need to win voter approval in both 2028 and 2030 to take effect.

