Trump axes Grad PLUS program, harming struggling students

President Donald Trump’s elimination of the Grad PLUS program limits lower and middle-income students’ access to graduate school through new student loan caps —  a thinly veiled attempt to benefit the richest Americans at the cost of everyone else.

The Department of Education (ED) instituted new loan limits using the argument that uncapped borrowing raises tuition prices despite evidence suggesting otherwise. Its reasoning only serves to mask the real goals of this administration — to limit education access to only the wealthy. 

The Grad PLUS program, administered by the ED, provided unlimited federal student loan funding for graduate students. The idea behind this program was simple: increase access to graduate programs for all students. And it worked. 

As undergraduate enrollment has decreased by 15%, graduate enrollment has increased by 9%. Now, new graduate degree federal student loans have limits. Professional degrees, such as JDs and MDs are capped at $50,000 a year, while “nonprofessional” degrees like business and psychology are all capped at $20,500. 

The ED’s reasoning? Lowering the amount of money available for students to borrow means colleges will have to reduce costs. 

This argument makes absolutely no sense. When SNAP benefits were cut last year, food did not magically become cheaper — it only limited people’s access to it. The same is true for student loans — when people have less money to spend, college prices do not miraculously go down. Instead, these loan caps are a transparent attempt to reduce graduate degree access to only the wealthy. The ED’s theory is not only fundamentally flawed, but gets at the larger issue with Trump’s attacks on higher education. 

By dismantling the ED and reducing access to graduate programs, Trump is chipping away at Americans’ strongest opportunity for economic mobility. 

The graduate student loan caps only serve to protect the rich while limiting the ability for the poor and middle class to gain wealth. If Trump’s actual goal was to make college cheaper, he would fund our education system, not destroy it.

The theory that implementing student loan caps will decrease tuition is not a novel one. This idea stems from the Reagan Administration’s then-Secretary of Education William J. Bennet, who famously wrote an op-ed for the New York Times in 1987 titled “Our Greedy Colleges.” In it, he argues that increased financial aid has enabled universities to blithely raise their tuition. He then posits that higher education is not underfunded, but instead underproductive — failing to keep prices below inflation rates.

This is not a fair criticism. Colleges do not benefit from the same economies of scale that allow businesses to become more efficient. As prices in every sector rise, from wages to insurance, colleges must raise their prices to produce the same product. Despite this, conservatives are now recycling Bennet’s philosophy to eliminate the Grad PLUS program. But was his hypothesis even true? No. 

Economist Robert Kelchen put Bennet’s theory to the test by performing comprehensive studies on business , law and medical school prices. His research concluded there is no evidence to support the idea that the Grad PLUS program raised tuition prices. Eliminating the program only furthers the education gap in America by barring lower and middle-income students from the same programs wealthy ones can attend. 

A recent study by the Federal Reserve Bank found that upwards of 30% of graduate students will be affected by this, ensuring the rich have exclusive access to the most prestigious and expensive graduate schools. 

So if the Grad PLUS program is not the problem, then why is graduate school getting more expensive? For one, many universities are starting new graduate programs due to increased demand, driving up initial costs. Graduate programs also tend to be more expensive relative to their undergraduate counterparts.

But universities cannot solely be blamed for rising tuition costs. It is unrealistic to expect college prices to stay the same forever. Not to mention, public universities are not for-profit corporations. Many essential programs operate at a loss. For example, medical degrees especially are “wildly unprofitable,” says Kelchen. Producing just one doctor can easily cost colleges over $1 million. Limiting the amount of money students can borrow will never change that. 

The Trump Administration has been attacking America’s higher education system by shredding the ED, bullying universities into ending their DEI policies and limiting lower and middle class students’ access to graduate school — all under the guise of “making college more affordable.” 

In reality, his only goal is to ensure graduate education is a privilege exclusively for the affluent.

Recent Articles

Related Stories

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here