Townsite Data Center near Boulder City rejected by federal appeals board

Approval for the construction of Townsite Data Center just outside of Boulder City was rejected last week by a federal appeals board and sent back to the Bureau of Land Management for additional environmental review.

Before the appeal, this was the first data center in the country to be approved on BLM’s public lands.

The developer, Townsite Solar 2 LLC, originally submitted an application to build the data center on city land, but the Boulder City planning commission voted against the proposal in May after a long period of public comment against the project. In response, the developer sent an application to BLM to build the project on nearby federal land.

TS2 was originally authorized to build a solar farm and had already received an environmental assessment from BLM to satisfy National Environmental Policy Act requirements. 

BLM approved the project in June using the previous environmental review, which measured the impacts of the solar farm development on the environment. Instead of completing a new environmental review for the updated project, BLM determined that a data center was “essentially like” a solar farm and didn’t need to conduct an additional review.

The project came to a halt on Sept. 1 when the Interior Board of Land Appeals found that the initial review was insufficient for a data center and potentially violated NEPA’s environmental review process requirements. 

In addition to Townsite Data Center, which has been sent back to the beginning of the approval process, BLM is considering at least an additional seven applications for data center projects on Nevada public land, listed as “pending,” according to a new map released by The Center for Western Priorities, a conservation and advocacy group.

The map shows at least 17 data center and 13 data center-related infrastructure projects awaiting approval from BLM across 24,000 acres of public land in Nevada, Arizona, Idaho, Oregon, Utah and Wyoming. Five cases are unable to be classified based on public land records, according to the map.

A cluster of three unclassified cases northeast of Las Vegas span about 2,880 acres altogether. The largest of the three is attached to known data center developer Copia GDC, LLC and is located near the Dry Lake Solar Energy Center operated by NV Energy. 

“None of these projects should move forward without a permitting framework that lets communities decide where, how, or if data centers get built,” CWP Deputy Director Lauren Bogard said in a press release. “That process must include robust, site-specific environmental review and public input opportunities, as well as meaningful, negotiated community benefits that ensure the public is compensated when private companies profit from public lands.”

President Donald Trump has pushed to accelerate federal construction of large-scale data centers and related infrastructure by easing federal regulations, including expediting project review and permitting processes. The directive came in a 2025 executive order, which aimed to “facilitate the rapid and efficient buildout” of AI data center infrastructure by “easing Federal regulatory burdens.”

“The Trump administration has not shown itself to be super interested in process and thoroughness,” said Kate Groetzinger, communications director for The Center for Western Priorities. “They don’t seem to care that much about doing things the right way or the

legal way.”

Thirteen members of Congress, including Nevada Democratic Reps. Dina Titus and Susie Lee, sent a congressional letter with 18 questions to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum on Sept. 24.

Lawmakers requested answers from Burgum by Oct. 8 about data center projects on public lands, including whether the department will ensure public involvement and input on project proposals.

“To date, the Trump administration has taken no effort to involve the American public in these data center plans – only industry executives,” the letter said.

They raised concerns about the Trump administration’s “concerning proclivity to skirt environmental reviews and cut the public out of the process” by expediting data center permits. 

They also noted that data centers have “massive” environmental impacts, including significant water consumption, noise and air pollution, land disruption and strain on the electrical grid, which would create a financial burden for everyday Americans due to rising energy costs.

Groetzinger said the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, the law that determines how BLM manages its public lands, does not clearly state whether data centers are an appropriate use of public lands. 

Title V, Section 501 of the law contains a provision that authorizes grants, issues and renewal of right-of-ways for “systems for generation, transmission, and distribution of electric energy.” This accounts for solar and wind farms, which produce energy.

“But data centers don’t produce energy; they use energy,” Groetzinger said. “So that provision doesn’t cover data centers.”

Another provision requires public lands to be managed in a way that supports public benefit, or to “best meet the present and future needs of the American people.” 

“I think if you asked a lot of Americans, they would not say that data centers benefit them,” Groetzinger said. “So I think that the administration would have to make a pretty strong case that data centers are a general public benefit, and then they also need to prove that data centers have to be on public lands.”

She believes the process for building data centers on public land is “legally very ambiguous” under current federal law and that there should be a comprehensive permitting process for data centers. 

“We know the public really does not like data centers. So I think they (the Trump administration) face a really steep battle in putting these on public lands,” Groetzinger said. “People will fight them. People are already fighting them, like in the Boulder City example.”

Recent Articles

Related Stories

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here